Review The Beatles- Magical Mystery Tour (1967) *****

album review

Catfish

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2024
Posts
218
Reaction score
252
Location
Texas
CRF citizens have been kind so far. Now, I am going into dangerous territory, and provide one that is more wildly accepted as iconic. I mean this one and Sargent Peppers have been so parsed, discussed, and studied, I am really treading on some dangerous turf here. So, if you think I am FOS, let me know. I've got my Asbestos suit on. :)

Classic Rock Album of the Day- The Beatles- Magical Mystery Tour (1967) *****

A while back, I watched the Movie, Yesterday. The flick that without much of a spoiler alert was a cinematic approximation of what the world would be like today, if the Beatles hadn't existed. The plot of the movie is the world has had some kind of dimensional blip, and a struggling singer/songwriter wakes up and finds that the Beatles, and a few other examples were things that never existed. After the shock, he recreates the songs from memory, and exploits it to his benefit. I'll leave it at that, but the thought itself, kind of gave me an inspiration to complete a review to augment their significant transition to this new phase of their historic musical career. It is crazy thinking how music would be different today, if the Beatles hadn't existed.

1967 was an amazing year for the Fab 4. Never had a group had a duo of two albums of the quality and impact ever been made in rock before or since. Sargent Peppers and this LP basically realigned rock in the space of 6 months. Rock had been transformed from Floppy Hair Beatlemania into Psychedelia almost instantly. Rubber Soul gave a slight taste, but these two iced it, Because, like none other, the Beatles were not only impactful, but they invented counterculture, Psychedelia, and basically redefined music of the era at their whim. These 2, like their earlier phases unleashed tsunamis of copy cats and a few others who masterfully furthered the genre.

Now for the hard part of the equation. Which was better? I actually could give a different answer in any given day. Style wise, they are pretty much interchangeable. The fact that these two albums were concieved, written, recorded in a matter of 6 months is utterly mind boggling. Never has any music act ever been "in the zone" than these four guys. Many years ago, I burnt a CD of these two in tandem, for road trips. They are so loved, because The Beatles are the epitome of "The No Filler Zone". Admitedly, there are a couple latter songs at the end that might be considered somewhat weak, these guys nailed it 98% of the time. Like on this album, not only is there no filler, there are no weaknesses. When i do these reviews, i enjoy a few zingers at the expense of band's product when they deserve it. The Beatles are unique in that is impossible to give any negative feedback. No one was as good at songwriting as them. No one even came close.

Of course I'd be amiss not mentioning that this is a psuedo-soundtrack to the incredible and incredibly bizarre movie by the same name. Any doubt around the band's dabbling with Hallucinogens were pretty much put to rest.

Fun Fact: The BBC banned "I am the Walrus" for the line in the lyric..... "you been a naughty girl you let your knickers down"

Side 1-
------------
Magical Mystery Tour- Desn't get much better. Throw the Title song in the mix at the onset, and tease the concept. Fantastic tune that uses an almost echo or bottom barrelled chorus. Takes twists and turns that highlight their mastery. 2

Fool on the Hill- A McCartney slanted number that has all his fine melodic exellence. An near child like nonsenical theme that has strangeness as it's delivery hits the mark as well as Paul's dozens and dozen of other classics. 8

Flying- Very unique Beatles song that outside a few "La La La"'s this is one of their rare instrumentals.. Also groundbreaking in some early keyboard wizardry, including Melotron. 7

Blue Jay Way- If you look at a per capita, pound per pound basis, George might have had the most songwriting talent in the band. Think aboout it.... he had the most successful solo career of the 4 in my opinion. But..... of his catalog this is not even in his Top 10. 9

Your Mother Should Know- Pleasant and airy, and the weakest of an absolutely great album- 11

I am the Walrus- Utterly Nonsensical, maybe the most famous of that variety in music. Fantastic use of not only lyrics but how the song ebbs and flows through meter changes and FX, and strings.... This song is well deserving of its status as a classic. Extra Fun Fact: Eric Burden (of the Animals) was the Egg Man, for what was found was for pretty scandalous reasons- 1

Side 2-
----------

Hello Goodbye- The most traditional sounding fare on this uber-wierd trip. 10+ on a scale of ten for pop sensibilities. Listen to Ringo's drumming. For someone who often was derided for his lack of technical skills, this is pretty good on a 1967 kit. 4

Strawberry Fields Forever- Another massive classic. You sure can notice the LSD kicking in. The bending and musical half step slurriing, is a poster child of psychedelia technique. The buzz like cello thrown, and other random musical add just adds to the equation- 3

Penny Lane- Much like on Hello Goodbye, this is a pop centric song. The Beatles were geniuses in the fact that they gave all their audiences what they wanted. You have pop, you have innovation, and you have what they added to establish new musical trends. 6

Baby You are a Rich Man- Doesn't it seem every song is a massive classic? Their incorporation of strange and alternative instrumentation just kills it. The Beatles were the gods of the trade that even while keeping the experimental hamster cage rolling, they were still cranking out hits and classics. 7

All You Need is Love- Almost as famous as this song, was the lineup who helped with the song and especially chorus. Hit after hit. This song almost single handed started the Peace and Love Hippy schtick. 5
 

recgord27

Walking down a dusty road
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Posts
10,048
Reaction score
15,779
Location
Back in the saddle
An interesting and informative review @Catfish. Thanks.
I see that you have used the US track listing of this album, which btw, was the only official cd re-release of a Beatles album with the US listing. All the other cds were released with the original UK listings.
The album was originally released in the UK as a double EP and in US as an lp. Apparently, the original UK listing makes more sense to the album (as it should be heard) but I like the filled-out version a little more, probably because of Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields Forever. I love the psychedelic feel of this album.
There are also quite a few variations of this album in different parts of the world, a few with completely different extra tracks.
 

BeatleMatt

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2022
Posts
3,946
Reaction score
4,660
Location
In The Land Of Submarines
When I was young and just starting my Beatles collection, I first bought Magical Mystery Tour as a cassette. (Side thought - how many of your cassettes in the 80’s began to squeal after a few years? Columbia Records produced some of the worst quality cassettes that so many of the tape wheels created wear friction and would begin to squeal. My cassette copy of Magical Mystery eventual did as well but Columbia cassettes were notorious for this.)
I digress. Ringo’s drumming is noticeably different on Magical Mystery Tour. There is more bass and deeper sound to his playing. Of course the songs were changing and becoming less about romance. So to did the sound and style of Ringo’s playing.

“Your Mother Should Know” was an instant hit for me. It’s my favorite lesser known song on MMT.
And I am compelled to mention the U.S. radio version of “Penny Lane”, with the extra trumpet flurry on the end. Thanks to a few years of hearing the promotional version of the song on AM radio and eventually, Capital’s Beatles Rarities.
 

Catfish

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2024
Posts
218
Reaction score
252
Location
Texas
When I was young and just starting my Beatles collection, I first bought Magical Mystery Tour as a cassette. (Side thought - how many of your cassettes in the 80’s began to squeal after a few years? Columbia Records produced some of the worst quality cassettes that so many of the tape wheels created wear friction and would begin to squeal. My cassette copy of Magical Mystery eventual did as well but Columbia cassettes were notorious for this.)
I digress. Ringo’s drumming is noticeably different on Magical Mystery Tour. There is more bass and deeper sound to his playing. Of course the songs were changing and becoming less about romance. So to did the sound and style of Ringo’s playing.

“Your Mother Should Know” was an instant hit for me. It’s my favorite lesser known song on MMT.
And I am compelled to mention the U.S. radio version of “Penny Lane”, with the extra trumpet flurry on the end. Thanks to a few years of hearing the promotional version of the song on AM radio and eventually, Capital’s Beatles Rarities.

I guess one thing, I should have mentioned, is that reviews, opinions etc, when it comes to music is purely subjective. There is and never will be an empirical formula for how good a song. There are no wrong or right opinions when it comes to tunes. It boils down to preferences and nuanced pre-disposed experiences and tastes.

Though I like to rank songs in a review, I know that the odds of another rock lover having the same seriatim is near zero. And in like your case with "Your Mother Should". In some reviews, I'll throw what my seem as a head scratcher as for ranking. In those cases, I like the pen the term "sleeper" as a description.

Which is why I was a little hesitant to do this review. I knew there might be some ultra-Beatle experts here, who know and understand this band 100X than I. Which Matt..... How do you rank the pair.... MMT/SP?
 

BeatleMatt

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2022
Posts
3,946
Reaction score
4,660
Location
In The Land Of Submarines
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band ranks higher than Magical Mystery Tour for me.
I won my first copy of Pepper on the radio and I just sat between the speakers of my parents’ stereo and listened to the entire album and loved it.
As I say, Magical Mystery Tour was one of my first Beatles albums on cassette. The vast majority of my Beatles albums are on vinyl so for a long time, this was an album that I always had in my car. Of course I had copied Revolver and Pepper’s to tape but it was a few years before I had a vinyl copy of Magical Mystery Tour. There was quite a bit of hiss on that cassette and the used, second pressing I had first was by comparison sounding more dull or not as high in fidelity.
I may have thrown away all my Beatles cassettes in misdirected disappointment once I had cd versions but today I do have two Magical Mystery Tour E.P.s, two cd versions, and two second pressing vinyl, Apple and Capitol and the Parlophone version in The Beatles L.P. Collection box set.

I think right now I would rank Magical Mystery Tour at #4.
 

dr wu

Dr Prog
Joined
Mar 18, 2020
Posts
1,686
Reaction score
2,346
Location
Indiana
Always liked MMT....some brilliant 'trippy' music and lots of fun.
BTW side B were the singles released in 1967.
But....would come in 5th or 6th place for me behind other Beatles lps.
 

RedSG

Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2023
Posts
43
Reaction score
48
Location
USA
MMT is one of my favorites (along with all their other albums!). There's some really good production. I still have the MMT songbook from the 60s.
 

Find member

Forum statistics

Threads
30,951
Posts
1,084,001
Members
6,466
Latest member
zeev512

Staff online

Members online

Top